Crumb & Crusta sourdough diary

A sourdough diary

One loaf, written down
properly at last

After four years and a great many mediocre loaves, this is the schedule that finally became repeatable in an ordinary kitchen — with the parts that actually matter marked as such, and the parts everyone frets about left where they belong.

500gflour350gwater100gstarter10gsalt

Two days, mostly waiting

Active work adds up to about forty minutes. Everything else is the dough doing its own thing while you get on with the day.

  1. 21:00

    Feed the starter

    Evening before. Equal weights flour, water, starter. It should roughly triple by morning if the kitchen is warm.

  2. 08:00

    Mix and rest

    Flour and water only, no starter yet. An hour of rest lets the flour hydrate — the dough becomes noticeably easier to handle.

  3. 09:00

    Add starter and salt

    Squeeze through until evenly distributed. It will look ragged. That is correct.

  4. 09:30–13:00

    Fold, four times

    A set of folds every 45 minutes. By the last set the dough should hold its shape and feel alive rather than slack.

  5. 13:00–16:00

    Bulk rise

    The part everyone rushes. Wait for a 50% rise and a domed, jiggly surface — not double, which is where most home loaves go wrong.

  6. 16:00

    Shape and chill

    Shape without knocking the air out, then into the fridge overnight. Cold dough is far easier to score.

  7. 08:00

    Bake

    Preheated pot, 20 minutes covered, 20–25 uncovered. Take it darker than feels comfortable.

Three things that changed everything

Weigh everything

Cups measure volume, and flour compacts. A cheap digital scale removes an entire category of failure.

Watch the dough, not the clock

Every timing on this page is a guess about your kitchen. A cold room can double the bulk rise, and no schedule can know that.

Under-proof rather than over

An under-proofed loaf is dense but edible. An over-proofed one spreads into a sad disc and cannot be rescued.

Everything else — the brand of flour, the shape of the banneton, whether you use a lame or a razor taped to a stick — turned out to matter far less than getting the bulk rise right.